What My Pinterest Analytics Taught Me About Running a Creative Business

An update about what I learned in Meagan Williamson's Pin Potential

what pinterest analytics taught me about running a creative business

When I wrote my first blog post about Meagan Williamson's Pin Potential, I talked about why I'd joined, what I appreciated about the program, and why learning Pinterest had started to feel a lot like gardening.


Planting seeds. Giving things time. Not expecting something wonderful to happen overnight.


Well, I've been checking on those seeds.


And some of them have been developing in a  rather interesting direction.

Apparently, my Pinterest account didn't need me for a month

Here's something I didn't expect.


Even though I have the best intentions, I don't always have time to accomplish all my goals and Pinterest is, regrettably, something that sometimes falls by the wayside. And so it happened, that I didn't publish a single new Pinterest pin for 30 days.


Not because I was conducting some clever experiment. I was simply busy with other things. Running katmeetsmouse designs alongside a full-time job means there are weeks when something has to give.

Pinterest was one of those things.


And yet, when I checked my analytics in early November, this is what I found:

  • 78,240 impressions, up 33%
  • 1,360 engagements, up 18%
  • 257 saves, up 7.9%
  • 20 outbound clicks, up 33%


All during a 30-day period without new pins.

Now, I'm not suggesting that abandoning Pinterest is a brilliant marketing strategy. Nor can I attribute those increases directly to Pin Potential. But it was a rather satisfying demonstration of something Meagan has been teaching all along: Pinterest works differently from other social media platforms where content tends to disappear from view almost as quickly as it arrives.


A pin can continue to be discovered long after you've published it.

And for someone who doesn't have endless hours to spend on marketing, that's a pretty compelling proposition.

The pins I spent the least time on were doing surprisingly well

Here's another discovery that made me look twice.


I've spent a fair amount of time creating beautiful mockups for my surface pattern designs. Carefully styled interiors, lovely fabrics, cushions, wallpaper. The sort of imagery that helps people imagine how a pattern might look in their own homes.


I enjoy making them, too. I added CTAs to my pins, I thought long and hard about where to add my logo or website URL. The works... 


But when I started looking more closely at which pins were actually performing well, I noticed something unexpected.


Some of my simplest pins, showing little more than the patterns themselves, were outperforming those elaborate mockups.


Particularly my retro geometric designs.


The lesson here wasn't that mockups are useless. They're most certainly not and they serve an important purpose, especially when someone wants to visualize a design in a real setting.


But I'd been making assumptions about what people would respond to, based largely on what I thought looked attractive.


My Pinterest audience, apparently, had a few opinions of its own.


So I'm experimenting with simpler formats and paying closer attention to which images generate saves, engagement, and actual clicks. And I'm spending a little less time polishing things that may not need quite so much polishing. And that's a very welcome development.

Meet Sophie. She's younger than I thought.

Like many creative business owners, I've spent time thinking about my ideal customer.


I'd even given mine a name: Sophie. And I had a fairly detailed picture of her life, her interests, and the kinds of things she might buy for her home.


Then I looked more closely at my Pinterest audience demographics. And discovered that the people seeing and engaging with my pins were younger than I'd expected. That doesn't necessarily mean my original customer profile was wrong. Pinterest analytics tell me about my audience on Pinterest, not everything about the people who eventually buy my designs.


But it did make me reconsider some assumptions I'd been treating as established facts. Who am I actually reaching? What interests them? Are the designs I think will appeal to a particular customer the ones attracting attention?


And, perhaps most importantly, am I creating for the audience I have, or the audience I've imagined?

Sophie is still around. I'm just getting to know her a little better.



Better questions, not magic answers

If there's one thread connecting these discoveries, it's that I'm learning to approach Pinterest with more curiosity and fewer assumptions. That has been one of the most useful aspects of Pin Potential for me.


Meagan doesn't simply hand you a list of things to do and promise that everything will work beautifully. She encourages you to understand what's happening, examine the evidence, and make decisions that fit your particular business.


And that distinction matters. Especially when you're working with limited time and a creative business that doesn't fit neatly into someone else's marketing formula.


I've started thinking more carefully about how my patterns are presented, what people might be searching for, and how Pinterest can help them discover my work. And I'm also beginning to connect individual marketing activities into something more coherent.


My seasonal pattern collections, for example, can become destinations for Pinterest visitors rather than simply collections of images scattered across different platforms. And projects such as my Winterberry Christmas printables give me opportunities to connect Pinterest discovery with my website and newsletter.


I'm still learning as I go along, figuring things out in the context of my particular business. But the pieces are beginning to fit together.


What about sales?

Let's address the obvious question: Have these Pinterest improvements translated into a dramatic increase in sales?


So far, not that I can demonstrate. And I want to be honest here. Impressions aren't sales. Neither are saves. Even outbound clicks don't automatically mean someone will buy something.


For me, twenty outbound clicks in 30 days is encouraging growth, but it's hardly a flood of potential customers.


What I do have is better visibility into what's working, a clearer understanding of where to focus my efforts, and growing evidence that some of the content I've already created can continue attracting attention.


Those are useful developments. Whether they eventually translate into more sales is something I'll keep watching, my fingers firmly crossed.



Back to the garden

In my first Pin Potential blog post, I wrote about Meagan comparing Pinterest to gardening.


That metaphor has stayed with me. And after looking at my recent results, I think I appreciate it even more.

Some of the seeds I planted months ago are still growing. Others haven't done much at all. A few are thriving in places I didn't expect.


The difference now is that I'm learning to look more closely at what's happening rather than simply planting more and hoping for the best.


What I've learned through Pin Potential is beginning to show its value in my analytics, my decisions, and the way I spend my time. But I'm also starting to see the practical value of what I've learned, in my analytics, my decisions, and the way I spend my time. For a small creative business, that's meaningful progress.


And I'm rather curious to see what grows next.

Interested in learning more about Pinterest?


Meagan Williamson offers two courses, depending on where you are in your Pinterest journey.


Pinterest Beginners Course

If you're just getting started with Pinterest and want to understand the basics, this is a good place to begin. The course covers the foundations, from setting up your account to creating pins and understanding how Pinterest works.

Explore the Pinterest Beginners Course (affilate link)


Pin Potential: The Signature Course

This is the program I've been part of myself. It takes a more comprehensive approach to Pinterest marketing, with training, practical guidance, and support to help you develop a strategy for your business.

Explore Pin Potential (affiliate link)


And a little note of transparancy:  If you decide to join through one of the affiliate links on my website, I may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you. I only share tools and programs that I genuinely believe are worth exploring, and I'm always clear about which ones I've used myself.


Pin Potential opens a few times a year, and when it does, I may occasionally share updates or invitations here, on Instagram, or in my newsletter.

Love creative insights, behind-the-scenes stories, and practical tips?
Get my
monthly newsletter straight to your inbox and snatch a freebie while you're at it. 

Sign up for the newsletter

☆ Keep on reading ☆


If you enjoyed this, there’s more where that came from. Around here, it’s all about patterns, process, and building a creative side business. Start with the latest posts, or dive into the categories:
❖
Patterns ❖ Studio Biz ❖ Toolkit ❖ Inspired ❖ Worth It